In Europe and the United States, the decline in academic performance points to an educational crisis that goes beyond learning difficulties and affects the school system’s ability to reduce social inequalities. The decline in basic skills, which began before the pandemic, is intertwined with the spread of digital technologies and artificial intelligence, whose impact depends increasingly on the quality of their use and the available resources. In the United States, media coverage focuses on the risks of cognitive delegation to AI, the influence of digital platforms, and economic disparities in access to the most innovative educational models. In Europe, the debate centers primarily on the effectiveness of pedagogical models, the role of the market, regional disparities, and the ability of public education to ensure social mobility. In the case of Russia, these challenges are compounded by the political dimension of control over content and educational autonomy.
European and U.S. coverage of education points to a fundamental fact: the decline in academic performance in high-income countries now appears to be a structural trend that predates the pandemic and has been exacerbated by the transformation of the digital environment. The PISA results show a significant decline in reading, math, and science skills in many Western education systems. As reported by the Financial Times, 15-year-olds in wealthy countries are now, on average, about a year and a half behind their peers from 2015 in reading; in the United States, reading scores are at their lowest levels in the past 25 years.
However, this phenomenon is not attributed to a single cause: among the factors discussed are a decline in reading habits, digital distractions, the erosion of basic skills, and, more recently, the use of AI that can replace rather than support cognitive effort.
The issue of AI thus shifts the debate from access to technology to the quality of its use. At U.S. universities, the debate is particularly heated: the risk highlighted by MIT is that of an “illusion of learning,” in which the speed with which a chatbot generates a response reduces independent study, interaction with professors and classmates, and the ability to retain what has been learned. One study A study of 26,000 Chinese students reveals the same ambivalence: performance on assignments completed with AI improves, but performance on tests taken without technology worsens. Universities’ responses remain fragmented, ranging from restrictions to integration into curricula and models that distinguish between exams in which AI is prohibited and those in which its use is explicitly required.
The Digital Education Council, too, now identifies the transition from experimentation to governance as the central issue: the adoption of AI requires infrastructure, expertise, common rules, and investment; otherwise, it risks depending on the initiatives of individual faculty members or departments and creating new disparities within universities themselves.
Finally, an international comparison highlights a particularly significant aspect of the AI issue: according to Andreas Schleicher of the OECD, in the highest-performing Asian education systems, technology is used by teachers to encourage students to think more deeply and work harder, whereas in Western systems, it has often been introduced to simplify schoolwork. The key difference lies in how technology is integrated into educational processes.
In the United States, the transformation of the educational environment also involves the relationship between schools and digital platforms. Meta is expanding its Instagram School Partnership Program, which has been joined by nearly 17,000 schools: originally created to allow schools to report incidents of bullying and safety issues, it now also enables communication with students and families through the platform and prioritizes reports from schools in its moderation process. This finding is significant because it shows that social media is formally becoming part of the school ecosystem—not merely a phenomenon to be restricted.
At the same time, the Alpha School model—a private network that uses adaptive AI tutors for part of the school day and devotes the rest to activities such as coding, entrepreneurship, and public speaking—takes the idea of a school organized around technological personalization to the extreme. However, tuition fees—ranging from $40,000 to $75,000 per year—highlight yet another aspect of inequality: access to the most advanced educational models also depends on families’ financial means.
In Europe, the decline in academic performance is manifesting itself in various ways and has reignited the debate over pedagogical and organizational models. For example, the debate over systems inspired by the Finnish model—which are characterized by greater autonomy, flexibility, and cross-curricular skills—has come under criticism, with some arguing that the reduced emphasis on structured curricula, foundational knowledge, and standardized assessments may have contributed to the decline in performance.
Tej Parikh, an economics columnist for the Financial Times, also interprets the crisis as the result of the interplay between technology, educational choices, and social conditions: AI can exacerbate the problem when used to delegate cognitive tasks, while it can enhance learning when it supports reasoning. From this perspective, the quality of teachers, the family environment, parental involvement, and socioeconomic conditions remain key factors.
Sweden is a particularly significant case because it raises questions about the relationship between universalism, the market, and the quality of education. The system of independent schools funded through vouchers—introduced in the 1990s and now used by about one in five children—was created with the goal of ensuring choice and free access even for lower-income families. However, the PISA results—the worst ever recorded by the country—have reignited the debate over the model’s effectiveness. The Social Democrats are calling for limits on profit distribution by private operators, while the latter defend the system’s ability to ensure efficiency and choice. Critics emphasize Furthermore, the ability to attract high-achieving students can influence the composition of schools and, consequently, the interpretation of results. The Swedish case thus demonstrates how a formally universal system can produce disparities through school choice, student composition, and resource allocation.
In the United Kingdom, however, the issue of inequality is primarily linked to the transition from school to work. Journalist Rachel de Souza argues that the British system has improved overall results but still does not guarantee equal opportunities for everyone: approximately 200,000 students each year fail their GCSE exams in math and English, and there are now 300,000 more young people out of work or out of school than there were five years ago. The problem therefore also concerns the school system’s ability to translate learning into skills, credentials, and employment. Career guidance and vocational training are recommended as tools for reducing this gap, provided they do not become a fallback option for students with lower academic performance.
France presents yet another perspective, in which declining academic performance translates into a broader perception of social injustice. The PISA results have become part of a broader narrative of the decline of the education system and of growing “declineism”—that is, the perception of social and national decline. The protests by students in the Paris suburbs are highlighting the shortage of teachers and resources, overcrowding, and the disparity between conditions in schools in working-class neighborhoods and those in central Paris. Mobilization through Snapchat and TikTok also shows how social media is both part of the educational environment and a tool for political participation. The French case thus highlights how educational disparities are not only reflected in international statistics but also in the physical conditions of schools and students’ perception that they have fewer opportunities than their peers.
Finally, Europe and the United States thus share a crisis of outcomes that is intertwined with technological transformation, but the responses and forms of inequality differ. In the United States, the debate is heavily focused on the impact of AI, the integration of social media into the school environment, and the growing disparity between educational models accessible to families with vastly different spending power. In Europe, the focus is primarily on the comparison of educational models, school organization, the role of the market, and the ability of public systems to address social inequalities.
In Russia, according to an analysis by The Economist, the government has gradually curtailed the autonomy of schools and universities, incorporating patriotic education, history reinterpreted from the Kremlin’s perspective, and military content related to the war in Ukraine into the curricula. These activities now extend even to very young children and include meetings with military personnel, military training, and youth programs. At the same time, international exchanges, foreign language instruction, and access to international curricula are being scaled back. From this perspective, education becomes a tool for building political identity and consensus. The British magazine notes, however, that this approach does not necessarily seem to foster ideological commitment: many students are bored, some parents have their children skip classes, and some teachers strip the lessons of their substance. Educational inequality also emerges here as inequality in access to knowledge, international perspectives, and a diversity of historical narratives.