Unequal education, unequal futures

by Nelson Ribeiro, CATÓLICA University Portugal

Author: Nelson Ribeiro, CATÓLICA University Portugal

Educational inequality is no longer only about access to school, but about whether education can be translated into meaningful learning, autonomy and future opportunity. Territorial, economic and social differences continue to shape the quality of students’ educational experiences, while artificial intelligence is creating a new divide between those who have the skills and resources to use it critically and those who risk being exposed to it without adequate support.

From this perspective, educational justice requires not only infrastructure and technology, but also strong human relationships, qualified teachers and adequate material conditions. AI can widen access and opportunity, but it can also reinforce existing inequalities if it is used as a substitute for, rather than a support to, human education.

Press coverage of the OECD’s PISA test results reveals that the global education debate varies by geography but centres on a common question: whether schooling gives every child a genuine opportunity to learn and develop their human potential. In many countries, particularly in parts of Africa, the immediate challenge is ensuring that every child can attend a functioning school. In wealthier countries, formal access is more widespread, but does not necessarily ensure that students acquire the knowledge and skills required to participate fully in society. These are not separate problems, but different expressions of the same failure to distribute fairly the conditions that lead to meaningful learning.

In many countries, particularly in some parts of Africa, the most urgent challenge remains ensuring that every child has access to a functioning school. In wealthier countries, by contrast, formal access to education is more widespread, but it does not guarantee that students acquire the knowledge and skills needed to participate fully in social life. These are not separate problems, but different manifestations of the same failure: the inability to distribute equitably the conditions that make meaningful learning possible.

Limited media coverage of education systems in Africa and parts of the Middle East is itself significant. International attention gravitates towards countries that generate comparable data, namely through the PISA test, while societies where deprivation is hardest to measure risk becoming less visible in the global arena. In fact, geography does not merely provide the backdrop to inequality; it actively shapes it. Rural isolation, urban segregation, conflict, displacement and uneven public investment determine the availability and quality of infrastructure and learning opportunities.

Furthermore, school attendance does not per se ensure that students have the support they need to learn, as the necessary conditions extend far beyond the classroom. They include secure housing, adequate nutrition, access to books, quiet study space, parental time, language support, transport, tutoring and extracurricular activities. Students also need guidance to engage critically with online information, especially before they have had the opportunity to develop the skills required to think independently. In Western countries, advantage increasingly derives from these resources rather than from attendance alone. Education policy cannot therefore treat low achievement as an isolated institutional problem, because it reflects a wider social settlement: some students arrive at school protected from instability while others carry the effects of poverty, migration, discrimination or insecurity into every lesson.

This account of how education systems reproduce and deepen existing inequalities acquires broader moral significance when read alongside the encyclical Magnifica Humanitas(2026). As Pope Leo XIV writes, “the fundamental dignity of each person […] is neither acquired nor earned, nor does it need to be justified” (no. 53). From that perspective, educational inequality is not merely an inefficiency to be corrected or a disappointing disparity in international results. It represents a denial of integral human development whenever a child’s place of birth, family income or social condition limits the possibility of learning and cultivating hope.

The principle that every person possesses irreducible dignity also provides a standard for evaluating educational technology. The relevant question is not simply whether a tool is innovative or widely available, but whether – and how – it advances each student’s integral development. Artificial intelligence makes this discussion more urgent because its educational value depends on the environment in which it is deployed. Although AI is often presented as a universal tutor capable of personalising instruction and widening access to knowledge, its availability and benefits are stratified. Some learners benefit from paid tools, state-of-the-art devices, fast internet connections, digitally confident teachers and adults who can help them assess an answer. Others encounter free or restricted systems through shared devices, weak connectivity and institutions without the capacity to provide guidance. The emerging divide is therefore not simply between those with and without AI, but between those able to use it critically and those exposed to it without adequate support.

Students with strong literacy, subject knowledge and confidence can formulate better questions, detect errors and use generated material as a starting point for deeper work. Those with weaker foundations are more likely to accept fluent but inaccurate output, substitute generation for comprehension or become dependent on assistance they cannot evaluate. If schools introduce AI before securing reading, numeracy, reasoning and media literacy, the technology may widen the divide between learners who use it to deepen understanding and those who cannot assess the output on which they rely.

The risks extend beyond individual use. Automated tutoring, assessment and monitoring systems reflect the training data, commercial priorities and design choices on which they are built, and may not adequately represent particular languages, cultures or curricula. At the same time, better-resourced schools and universities are more likely to use AI as an additional resource under close human supervision, while poorer communities may receive it as a replacement for teachers, counsellors or specialist support. This could create a two-tier model across education: human-rich provision for those with greater resources and increasingly automated provision for those with fewer.

Saint John Henry Newman argued that education is a formative human practice grounded in intellectual cultivation and human relationships. It develops not only competencies but also the capacity to reason, relate different forms of knowledge and judge truth critically (The Idea of a University, Discourses V–VI). Because such formation depends on personal encounter, an algorithm may support these purposes but cannot assume a teacher’s moral responsibility or replace the relationships that foster trust, dialogue and solidarity. Teachers attend to persons whose needs, abilities, fears and aspirations cannot be fully captured by performance indicators. Through professional judgement, they recognise when a student needs to be challenged, reassured or corrected. That discernment is moral as well as technical because it entails responsibility for the student as a person, not merely for academic performance.

Protecting the role of the teacher is therefore a necessary condition of educational justice. Where staff are unstable, classes are overcrowded and professional training is insufficient, AI more easily risks becoming a cheap substitute for human support. Communities already affected by poverty, geographical isolation or conflict would end up bearing the greatest costs, further reinforcing the two-tier educational model described above. Artificial intelligence can broaden opportunities, but it can also aggravate disadvantage. Whether it reduces or widens inequalities depends on how it is governed: whether it is put at the service of human dignity or used to conceal a lack of resources and human relationships. Educational justice therefore begins with access, but is fully realised only when every student can share in the material conditions and human relationships needed to make authentic learning possible.

Topic
Related
AI has already made its way into schools. Now we need to regulate it.
How Students’ Learning Levels Are Changing: The 2025 PISA Tests
School should reduce inequalities. In Italy, it risks perpetuating them.
When School Ceases to Be a Path to Social Mobility
Top-Ranked Schools, Unequal Opportunities: The Two Sides of Asian Education
The Middle East: Two Schools and Two Futures
Artificial intelligence alone is not enough to bridge Africa’s educational gaps
In South America, education alone is not enough to overcome inequality